barna.org
The research found that there are two types of people being attracted to house churches. The older participants, largely drawn from the Boomer population, are devout Christians who are seeking a deeper and more intense experience with God and other believers. The other substantial segment is young adults who are interested in faith and spirituality but have little interest in the traditional forms of church. Their quest is largely one of escaping outdated structures and institutions.
The survey also indicated that there is likely to be more change in the house church environment in the years to come. The ideas of worshiping in homes rather than church buildings, and being led by group members rather than religious professionals, are new to most Americans. The survey suggested that many people are just beginning to think about, and get comfortable with, the idea of homes being the dominant place for shared faith experiences.
Interestingly enough, Rick Warren (Pretty much the epicenter of the problem) has even noticed — though his solutions are, as yet, pretty much the same drivel:
The truth is many people are very open to learning about God and spiritual issues, they just don’t feel welcome at church or feel that it has anything to offer them. That is our problem.
Barna isn’t telling most of us anything new really — he’s just got numbers to back him. Anyone who hasn’t figured out that the members of the evangelical church are rather rapidly draining out the door has been living under a rock.
There’s both an ironic difference and similarity between the two of them though: Barna has figured out that the traditional bricks and mortar church is already facing a tidal wave and it isn’t going to end. Warren still thinks that if he just hypes up the same-old-same-old a little, people will be back. Neither of them, however, has seemed to figure out what is causing it.
Truth is, it isn’t that the young people are really trying to escape institutions — they are basically agnostic towards the existence and validity of those structures. It isn’t that the adults are seeking something deeper — they are fleeing a place where depth is impossible because it is fundamentally opposed to the core message of the Gospel. Somewhere along the line, the unthinkable happened. These people sat down and reread for the very first time those little known books called Romans, Galatians and some other weird names — much, I suspect, to the horror of their church leaders.
They discovered the unmentionable: That the ethical rantings of the evangelical church have been delivered by pastors who had actually been taught the Gospel — but preferred to use legalism to control their flock. They discovered that those people Paul calls, “The Judizers,” or “Those who are of the circumcision,” were at the helm. They discovered that a Church that should have been leading people to maturity preferred to keep them in infancy — because it made a lot of money to build big buildings. They discovered it — and they wanted more. The sad part of this is that all of those churches could keep their members and gain thousands more — if they would just put aside their power, fear and control issues and listen (for a change) to what we have known for hundreds of years.
Father Hughes, in his work God of Surprises, comments on von Hugel’s critical analysis in his two volume work called The Mystical Element in Religion, saying:
Von Hugel takes the three main stages in human development – infancy, adolescence and adulthood – describing the predominant needs and activities which characterize each stage. He shows that religion must take account of and nurture the predominant needs and activities of each stage, and so concludes that religion must include three essential elements, an institutional element corresponding to the needs and activities of infancy, a critical element corresponding to adolescence, and a mystical element corresponding to adulthood. As he analyzes each stage of growth, he is careful to show that the needs and activities of infancy do not disappear in adolescence, nor do the needs and activities of adolescence disappear in adulthood, but they should cease to be predominant if we are to grow into the following stage.
The Institutional: People need structure to get a life of broken chaos under control.
The Critical: People need to be allowed to think for themselves and to do the necessary questioning of the idea that the rules are even relevant in a Gospel of Grace and Freedom.
The Mystical:
People are walked into a deep and intimate relationship with Jesus and the entirety of their faith comes down to listening to the voice of God and following.
The key reality that none of these people get is that ethics based religion barely is even useful for those in the Institutional stage of their faith. It is clearly an insult to God Himself at any other stage and considerably offensive to a person in such. People are finally tired of being spoon fed the past Words of God — and a very edited set at that — and are longing to hear the current Word of God deep in their own hearts.
What’s happening? The church is finally waking up and seeking the face of God instead of religion — which, rather ironically, is what Jesus came to suggest in the first place. The operators of those multi-million dollar religious structures are going to have to do with Jesus what the Jews also had to do with Him 2000yrs ago if they want to keep the same control focused, ethics driven and Institutional religion based structures going.
But hey, probably no one will even notice — it’s not like that’s a change or anything… Galatians 3:1-9 (Well, except for the nearly 50% of Evangelical believers whom researchers suggest are already out the door…)